The Wire
Geneva agrees a two-year path to “killer robots” rules; but not whether they will bind
After five days of talks that ran past 4 a.m., the 128 states of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons agreed to elaborate an international instrument on lethal autonomous weapons; leaving open the question campaigners care about most: will the rules be legally binding?
Key points
- The agreement: After five days of talks that ran past 4 a.m. on Saturday 21 November, the 128 states party to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons agreed to launch the elaboration of an international instrument on lethal autonomous weapons systems over the next two years. 2
- The wording: The states agreed to “elaborate” an instrument, not to “negotiate” one; some delegations objected to the word “negotiate”. Conference president Julien Thöni said the process should flesh out which weapons can be forbidden under international humanitarian law and which can be regulated. 2
- The split: Around 100 countries backed legally binding rules within a short timeframe, but the United States, Russia and Israel opposed them, leaving open whether future measures will be legally binding. 1
- The definition: The expert group preparing the talks agreed in early September on a first characterisation of a lethal autonomous weapon: weapons and integrated components that can identify, select and engage a target without intervention by a human operating the system. 7
- The reaction: “States adopted a watered-down mandate that fails to chart a clear path towards a legally binding instrument,” said the Stop Killer Robots coalition. Human Rights Watch called the outcome “disappointing”. 2
ONE EVENT. THREE READINGS.
The West has treated the talks as a problem of legal architecture.
Reuters’ coverage, carried across Western outlets, framed the week as a negotiation between three texts; a draft protocol by 2028, a seven-country push for binding negotiations, and an American paper asking for five more years of voluntary guidance.
What this reading highlights: The split inside the West is the story: the United States, Russia and Israel, the states with the technology, against a majority of around 100 that includes most of Europe.
France wants a new negotiating mandate that bans fully autonomous systems; Britain, meanwhile, has declined to back a legally binding treaty. The Western reading is that consensus gives every state a veto; and that the veto is now the obstacle.
Sources: Reuters (1), SWI swissinfo (1), Tech Times (1)
The East’s coverage carried the outcome straight and fast.
Singapore’s CNA and Malaysia’s Free Malaysia Today both led with the agreement itself, the two-year elaboration, the watered-down mandate, the campaigners’ disappointment, while Japan’s Nikkei ran the Reuters account of the 4 a.m. finish.
What this reading highlights: The Asian angle is the technology race: China abstained in the General Assembly committee’s October vote, one of nine abstentions, and the region’s reporting stresses that the systems under discussion are already being built and deployed.
For the East, the question is less whether rules will come than whether a two-year clock can keep pace with the arsenals.
Sources: CNA (1), Free Malaysia Today (1), Nikkei Asia (1)
The Global South’s voice in Geneva was the push for binding rules.
The seven-country proposal for negotiations on a legally binding agreement included Brazil, Mexico and Panama, and Brazil’s ambassador to the Conference on Disarmament, Frederico Meyer, said on the final day that “a minority of states continue to block progress, acting in the interests of tech bosses and arms profiteers.” Saudi Arabia’s Arab News carried the outcome to the region.
What this reading highlights: The Southern reading is blunt: the states that would live with autonomous weapons on their battlefields, in Sudan, in the Middle East, have the least power under a consensus rule that lets the builders of the technology set the pace.
Sources: Arab News (1)
Sources by lens: 3 West, 3 East, 1 Global South. See every source
THE POINT OF CONVERGENCE
On the facts. After five days of talks in Geneva that ran past 4 a.m. on Saturday 21 November, the 128 states party to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons agreed to launch the elaboration of an international instrument on lethal autonomous weapons systems over the next two years. The mandate leaves open whether the eventual rules will be legally binding.
WHAT REMAINS CONTESTED
On what the agreement means. Around 100 states, the campaigners and the UN leadership read the two-year mandate as a delay that leaves civilians exposed while the technology races ahead. The United States, Russia and Israel read it as the right pace: a voluntary instrument, they argue, can be updated as the technology changes and applies to every state at once, while a protocol binds only those that ratify it.
The story
What did 128 states agree at 4 a.m. in Geneva?
GENEVA, After five days of talks that ran past 4 a.m. on Saturday, the 128 states party to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons agreed to open a two-year process to develop rules for lethal autonomous weapons systems, the machines often called “killer robots” that can identify, select and engage targets with little or no human oversight.
The talks, which opened on Monday 16 November at the Palais des Nations, had been scheduled to end on Friday. They ran into overtime as diplomats searched for wording every delegation could accept under the convention’s consensus rule, which lets any single state block a decision.
The agreement, announced by the conference president, Swiss ambassador Julien Thöni, commits the states to “launch the elaboration of an international instrument on lethal autonomous weapons systems, which should be conducted over the next two years.” It keeps the door open to a binding protocol; but it does not promise one.
What does the two-year mandate actually contain?
First, the wording. The states agreed to “elaborate” an international instrument; not to “negotiate” one. Thöni told reporters that some countries had objected to the word “negotiate”, and the delegations settled on “elaborate” instead. The process ahead, he told AFP, should flesh out “which weapons can be forbidden according to international humanitarian law and which are not forbidden but can be regulated.”
Second, the numbers. Around 100 countries went into the week backing legally binding rules within a short timeframe. The big arms-producing nations, the United States, Russia and Israel, opposed that, and the agreement they accepted leaves open whether future measures will be legally binding at all.
Third, the definition. The expert group that prepared the talks agreed in early September on a first characterisation: a combination of weapons and integrated technological components that can identify, select and engage a target without a human intervening. That definition is now the working basis for the two-year process.
Fourth, the urgency. The talks were driven by alarm over the use of such systems in Ukraine, Sudan and the Middle East. The UN secretary-general, António Guterres, addressed the conference by video on Monday, and the Pope and the Red Cross have all called for strong and legally binding rules. In Sudan, where the Security Council has extended an arms embargo, the gap between existing controls and battlefield reality is already visible.
killer robots.
What the agreement leaves deliberately unsaid
The text does not say whether the eventual instrument will be legally binding. It does not say whether the expert group will receive a mandate to negotiate a protocol, or only to elaborate an instrument whose legal force is decided later. It sets no date for a draft protocol, only a two-year window for the elaboration itself.
Nor does it settle what “meaningful human control” means in practice, the phrase at the centre of a decade of talks, or how the rules would apply to systems already deployed on battlefields. No verification mechanism was agreed, and no state committed to pause development or deployment while the talks continue.
Why does a two-year delay matter when the weapons are already in use?
Because the decision at stake is who, or what, takes a human life. A lethal autonomous weapon selects and engages its target without a human taking the final decision. Handing that power to software is, in the words of campaigners, a line that should never be crossed without law behind it.
The delay matters because the technology is not waiting. “Autonomous weapons technology, including AI in the targeting cycle, is being deployed on the battlefield,” said Nicole van Rooijen, executive director of the Stop Killer Robots coalition. Human Rights Watch called the outcome “disappointing”: “It does not provide the urgent action needed to agree on new rules but the technology is racing ahead,” said Verity Coyle.
It also matters as a precedent. The rules written for autonomous weapons will shape how every other military use of artificial intelligence is governed; and whether the states that build the technology, or the majority that would live with its consequences, write those rules.
Elaborate, not negotiate: the verb that saved the talks
The week’s real negotiation was over a single verb. Three texts competed for the conference’s future. The chair of the committee handling the issue, Peru’s ambassador Elmer Schialer, circulated a draft in October that would have the expert group negotiate a new protocol, meet 15 days a year in 2027 and 2028, and hand a draft protocol to the meeting of states parties in 2028.
A cross-regional group of seven countries, Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand and Panama, went further, proposing negotiations on a legally binding agreement. The United States went the other way: a working paper dated 4 November asks for five more years of work toward a non-binding instrument, with a first version in 2029 and a report in 2031.
The outcome sits between the chair’s draft and the American paper. It adopts the two-year horizon of the chair’s text but drops the word “negotiate”; and with it the commitment to a draft protocol by 2028. “In the end, the military powers managed to impose many obstacles to the objective of a protocol, but at least it remains a possibility, and with a short-term mandate,” a diplomat who attended the talks told Reuters. France, for its part, wants a new negotiating mandate and an instrument that bans fully autonomous systems and regulates systems with autonomous functions.
The result is best read as a clock, not a treaty. The two-year mandate is short by the standards of a forum that has discussed the issue for more than a decade without opening negotiations. Whether it becomes a runway to a protocol or a holding pattern depends on what the expert group is told to do in 2027. The global race to regulate artificial intelligence is moving faster in capitals than in Geneva; and the gap is now the story.
What happens to the consensus rule now?
The week opened with a warning about the forum itself. On Monday, Russia objected to allowing observers, including the European Union and civil society organisations, to take part in the debate, and without its assent the conference could not adopt its agenda. The session was suspended; informal consultations followed on Tuesday. It showed, before any substance was discussed, that the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons decides by consensus; and any one of its 128 parties can stop everything.
That rule is now the second-order question. The wider United Nations is moving faster than the CCW: on 29 October, the General Assembly’s First Committee voted 163 to 5, with 9 abstentions, for a resolution on lethal autonomous weapons systems, and the full Assembly is expected to take it up in plenary in December. If Geneva stalls again, the pressure to move the issue outside the consensus-bound convention will grow; campaigners have already said so. Meanwhile the states that build the technology keep building it: military AI software is now a European industrial race, and even domestic agencies are organising against rogue drones.
What comes next before 2028?
The expert group meets again in 2027, under a mandate to elaborate the instrument over two years. The chair’s earlier draft envisaged a progress report in 2027 and a draft protocol handed to the 2028 meeting of states parties; whether the agreed mandate supports that timetable is the first fight of the new process.
Two clocks now run in parallel. In New York, the General Assembly is expected to take up the First Committee’s resolution in plenary in December. In Geneva, the campaign for a binding instrument continues; and if the consensus rule blocks a protocol again, the call to negotiate outside the CCW will get louder.
What we agree on, and what remains open
Established
- On the facts. After five days of talks in Geneva that ran past 4 a.m. on Saturday 21 November, the 128 states party to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons agreed to launch the elaboration of an international instrument on lethal autonomous weapons systems over the next two years. The mandate leaves open whether the eventual rules will be legally binding.
Contested
- On what the agreement means. Around 100 states, the campaigners and the UN leadership read the two-year mandate as a delay that leaves civilians exposed while the technology races ahead. The United States, Russia and Israel read it as the right pace: a voluntary instrument, they argue, can be updated as the technology changes and applies to every state at once, while a protocol binds only those that ratify it.
Still open
- Whether the instrument will be legally binding.
- Whether the expert group will be told to negotiate a draft protocol by 2028 or only to elaborate an instrument of undecided force.
- What “meaningful human control” will mean in practice.
- Or whether the consensus rule will let a single state block the next step as it nearly blocked this one.
What to watch
Questions, answered
The 128 states party to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons agreed to launch the elaboration of an international instrument on lethal autonomous weapons systems over the next two years. The agreement, reached in the early hours of Saturday 21 November after five days of talks, keeps open the possibility of a binding protocol; but it does not commit to one, and it sets no date for a draft.
It is a weapon system that can identify, select and engage a target without a human intervening in those tasks. The expert group preparing the Geneva talks agreed that characterisation in early September. The systems are often called “killer robots”, and alarm is growing over their use in Ukraine, Sudan and the Middle East.
Because the majority of states went into the week wanting legally binding rules within a short timeframe, and the agreement delivers neither a binding commitment nor a timetable for a draft protocol. The Stop Killer Robots coalition said the mandate “fails to chart a clear path towards a legally binding instrument”, and Human Rights Watch called it disappointing.
The United States, Russia and Israel, the big arms-producing nations with the technology, opposed legally binding rules. Around 100 countries backed them. The United States instead proposed five more years of work toward a non-binding instrument, with a first version in 2029. The convention decides by consensus, so any one of the 128 states can block a decision.
The expert group meets in 2027 to elaborate the instrument over two years, and the General Assembly is expected to take up the First Committee’s resolution on autonomous weapons in plenary in December. Campaigners will press for a draft protocol by 2028; and if the consensus rule blocks progress again, they say the negotiations should move outside the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons.
MAGNA BUREAU