The Wire
COP31 enters its final day with no deal; and no mention of fossil fuels
Negotiators in Antalya have until Friday to agree a deal among nearly 200 countries. The latest draft, published on Thursday, drops every reference to coal, oil and gas; and the $120bn adaptation figure Africa demanded.
Key points
- The deadline: COP31 is scheduled to end on Friday 20 November 2026 in Antalya, Türkiye, after two weeks of talks among nearly 200 countries, with negotiations expected to spill into the weekend. 1
- The revised draft: Published on Thursday by co-host Australia, the nine-page text was cut from 144 paragraphs to 80 and contains no mention of fossil fuels, coal, oil or gas. 6
- What was dropped: The first draft, published on Monday, called for accelerated action to phase out fossil fuels and for wealthy nations to reach net zero by 2030. 5
- The finance figure: The revised draft removed a proposed $120bn a year in adaptation finance for developing countries by 2035, leaving only a call for further discussions toward tripling adaptation finance. 7
- Africa’s demand: The African Group of Negotiators is pushing for adaptation finance to be tripled by 2035 from an annual $40bn baseline, a proposal not accepted for formal negotiations at the summit. 4
ONE EVENT. THREE READINGS.
In the Western reporting, the story is a negotiation to be saved.
Reuters, the BBC and Le Temps converge on the same facts, the stripped draft, the Friday deadline, the overtime pattern, and on the same question: whether a thin deal beats no deal.
What this reading highlights: The Western lens counts the concessions, notes the European Union’s own envoy called the first draft untenable, and reads Europe’s answer to Africa as fiscal realism, not refusal.
The Eastern coverage reads the summit through energy security.
CNA, The Hindu and Asia Today all record the same pivot: from the phase-out fight to the electrification pledge, from a binding text to voluntary promises.
What this reading highlights: India, among the countries seeking to delay the IPCC reports until 2029, is cautious on the science fight, while Nepal’s floods and a record El Niño supply the urgency.
The Eastern lens asks what a world that cannot agree on coal can offer countries already paying for its burning.
Sources: CNA (1), The Hindu (1), Asia Today (1), Deccan Chronicle (1)
The Global South lens starts where the damage is.
Al Jazeera, reporting from Antalya since the opening day, has kept the focus on the finance gap and on the small island states demanding a phase-out; Vanuatu’s protest and Antigua and Barbuda’s demand for a commitment with teeth.
What this reading highlights: The BBC’s reporting from Uganda and Malawi supplies the human ledger: failed harvests, swept-away homes, fifty disasters since 1980.
For the South, the missing $120bn is not a drafting detail; it is the measure of whether the summit was ever for them.
Sources: Al Jazeera (1)
Sources by lens: 2 West, 4 East, 1 Global South. See every source
THE POINT OF CONVERGENCE
On the facts. COP31’s revised draft, published on Thursday by co-host Australia, removes every mention of fossil fuels and drops the $120bn adaptation finance figure proposed in the first draft. Talks among nearly 200 countries in Antalya run to their scheduled close on Friday 20 November, with overtime expected, and the draft records deep concern that the 1.5°C limit is about to be breached.
WHAT REMAINS CONTESTED
On what a thin deal is worth. The presidency and its defenders say the most ambitious outcome consensus allows is better than collapse, and that the COP28 commitment to move away from fossil fuels stands even unwritten. Campaigners and vulnerable states call the erasure a glaring regression, and argue that a text silent on the cause of warming cannot credibly claim to address it.
The story
The draft that deleted fossil fuels
The United Nations climate talks in Antalya enter their final scheduled day on Friday 20 November with no agreement in sight, after a revised draft deal published on Thursday removed every mention of fossil fuels. Negotiators from nearly 200 countries have spent two weeks in the Turkish Mediterranean city trying to bridge differences that now threaten to push the summit into the weekend.
The new text was released by COP31 co-host Australia, whose climate minister, Chris Bowen, is steering the negotiations. It runs to nine pages, cut down from 144 paragraphs to 80, and it contains no reference to coal, oil or gas; the fuels driving the warming the summit exists to confront. An earlier draft, published on Monday, had called for accelerated action to phase them out.
France’s ecological transition minister, Monique Barbut, called the omission a ‘black mark’ on the talks. ‘We are going to fight for clean electrification,’ she said, as delegations headed into a final night of consultations with the deadline hours away.
What do the two drafts actually say?
The Monday text, eighteen pages long, called on wealthy nations to reach net zero emissions by 2030 and included wording on phasing out fossil fuels that oil-producing countries have long resisted. It also proposed at least $120bn a year in adaptation finance for developing countries by 2035. The Thursday text drops both: the fossil-fuel language is gone entirely, and the $120bn figure has been replaced by a call for further discussions toward tripling adaptation finance. Magna Bureau reported on the first draft
What survived is Türkiye’s flagship idea: a voluntary pledge to raise electricity to 35 per cent of final energy demand by 2035, from roughly a fifth today, backed by about 75 nations. The draft nods to the initiative, saying electrification could bring ‘significant benefits’ for energy security and emissions; but it does not require the extra electricity to be clean.
The draft also welcomes efforts to scale up carbon capture, utilisation and storage, and expresses ‘deep concern’ about the imminent breach of the 1.5°C limit set by the 2015 Paris Agreement. On science, the timing of the next Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change reports is unresolved: dozens of countries want them before a global review of climate efforts in 2028, while a smaller group including Saudi Arabia and India wants them postponed until 2029.
on the talks.
Five questions for the last night in Antalya
First, whether any mention of fossil fuels returns to the final text. The Thursday draft is not the final word, it is expected to be revised further, but every hour without that language makes its return harder, and oil producers have resisted it since COP28.
Second, whether adaptation finance gets a number at all. The African Group of Negotiators is pushing for finance to be tripled by 2035 from a $40bn annual baseline it says developed countries committed to by 2025. Africa’s demand, and Europe’s answer, is the sharpest North-South divide in Antalya, and the proposal was not accepted for formal negotiations.
Third, whether the electrification target gains the word ‘clean’. Fourth, when the talks actually end: the final text is due by midnight in Antalya on Friday, but recent summits have regularly run more than 24 hours past their deadlines, and observers expect at least one extra night.
Fifth, what lies behind the draft’s singling-out of Vanuatu. Vanuatu’s climate minister, Ralph Regenvanu, said his country ‘had been singled out for special attention that it doesn’t deserve’. The precise provision has not been made public.
The year 1.5°C moved from target to epitaph
The stakes are written into the draft itself. It expresses deep concern about the imminent breach of 1.5°C agreed in Paris in 2015 and independent analysis published last week by Climate Action Tracker found progress in slowing warming has essentially stalled for five years. On current promises, the planet is heading for 2.6°C by the end of the century, and the 1.5°C overshoot is now certain. Nations at COP31 are already grappling with the loss of the target.
For the countries most exposed, the argument is not abstract. In Uganda’s Karamoja region, seven months without rain have destroyed crops, with local officials reporting more than 90 per cent of crops failed; in Malawi, floods displaced families in Chikwawa barely a year after Cyclone Freddy, in a country hit by more than 50 climate-linked disasters since 1980. Yet 23 African countries have still not submitted national adaptation plans to the UN, which experts say makes funding far harder to secure.
And the process itself is on trial. Nations agreed at COP28 in Dubai in 2023 to transition away from fossil fuels, without targets or timelines. Last year’s summit in Brazil ended with no mention of fossil fuels at all. If Antalya repeats that, the central cause of warming will go unmentioned two summits in a row.
How a phase-out became a blank space
The deletion was not an accident; it was the price of consensus. Climate decisions require agreement among nearly 200 countries. The Monday draft tried to hold the line on two fronts at once, a fossil-fuel phase-out and a $120bn finance figure, and the room pulled it apart from both sides: oil producers against the phase-out, and the European Union’s climate envoy, Wopke Hoekstra, calling the draft untenable and in need of significant change.
Faced with that, co-host Australia did what presidencies do when the clock runs out: it published a text thin enough to survive. Bowen was candid, negotiators sought ‘the most ambitious outcome that consensus will allow’, and his promise, ‘We won’t be leaving the rooms of Antalya until we have that consensus,’ reads as both pledge and warning. COP31 president Murat Kurum insisted the summit was not stepping back.
The critics see a different ledger. ‘Countries beholden to fossil fuel interests are blocking progress on a fast, fair transition away from fossil fuels,’ said Rachel Cleetus of the Union of Concerned Scientists. The UN’s own climate chief, Simon Stiell, insisted the COP28 commitment stands: ‘You do not erase that.’ The question Antalya must answer is whether a commitment that no longer appears in the text still binds anyone.
Underneath the drafting fight sits the war in Iran and the oil price shock it set off. Türkiye’s answer, electrify everything, fast, promises energy independence without saying what powers it.
What a blank space in Antalya sets in motion
If the final text stays silent on fossil fuels, the work moves outside the UN process; as it began to do after last year’s summit in Brazil. Coalitions of the willing would become the vehicle for the transition, leaving the poorest to negotiate finance without the biggest emitters in the room. The United States, the world’s second-largest polluter and its largest historical emitter, has now skipped the talks for a second year in a row.
Finance would fragment with it. Without a number in the text, adaptation money flows through bilateral deals and voluntary channels, where leverage belongs to donors. For African negotiators, that is the real defeat hidden inside the drafting fight: not the missing words, but the missing figure.
Meanwhile the electricity race accelerates on its own terms. Türkiye has also launched a voluntary Antalya Artificial Intelligence Pledge, aimed at cutting the environmental cost of AI even as the technology adds to power demand. If the 35 per cent electrification target is met with coal and gas power, Antalya will have delivered growth in demand without the transition it was meant to drive.
One night left, then the road to 2028
Friday is the final scheduled day. Closing plenary sessions began on Thursday even as the tracks on finance, adaptation and a just transition remained unresolved, and the final text is due by midnight in Antalya. Bowen is consulting delegations through the night, and observers expect at least one extra night of talks before any gavel falls.
Three things decide whether Antalya is remembered as a salvage or a surrender: whether any fossil-fuel language returns to the text; whether adaptation finance regains a figure, and whose figure it is; and whether the electrification target is qualified with the word clean. A text that restores one of the three gives the summit something to stand on. A text that restores none of them still counts as a deal; and will be judged as one.
Beyond Friday, the road runs to the 2028 global stocktake, the review of every country’s climate efforts, and to the unresolved question of when the IPCC’s next assessments arrive. The small island states that pushed hardest in Antalya, Vanuatu, Antigua and Barbuda, will carry the argument into every forum that follows. The disputes inside the summit, from South Africa’s nuclear push to the finance fight, show a process straining under its own consensus rule.
What we agree on, and what remains open
Established
- On the facts. COP31’s revised draft, published on Thursday by co-host Australia, removes every mention of fossil fuels and drops the $120bn adaptation finance figure proposed in the first draft. Talks among nearly 200 countries in Antalya run to their scheduled close on Friday 20 November, with overtime expected, and the draft records deep concern that the 1.5°C limit is about to be breached.
Contested
- On what a thin deal is worth. The presidency and its defenders say the most ambitious outcome consensus allows is better than collapse, and that the COP28 commitment to move away from fossil fuels stands even unwritten. Campaigners and vulnerable states call the erasure a glaring regression, and argue that a text silent on the cause of warming cannot credibly claim to address it.
Still open
- Whether fossil-fuel language or a finance figure returns in the final text.
- Whether electrification will be qualified as clean.
- When the talks will actually end.
- Or what provision singled out Vanuatu in the draft. The final text is due by midnight on Friday in Antalya, and it can still change.
Questions, answered
COP31 is the 31st annual United Nations climate conference, held in Antalya, Türkiye, in November 2026. Nearly 200 countries are negotiating a deal on cutting emissions, adapting to warming and paying for the damage already done. The summit was scheduled to end on Friday 20 November, but climate talks regularly run into overtime.
The revised text, published on Thursday by co-host Australia, removed all references to coal, oil and gas after oil-producing countries resisted the phase-out language in the first draft. Decisions require consensus among nearly 200 countries, so any single delegation can block the text. The UN climate chief insists the COP28 commitment to move away from fossil fuels still stands.
The first draft proposed at least $120bn a year in adaptation finance for developing countries by 2035. The revised draft dropped the number, leaving only a call for further discussions toward tripling finance. The African Group wants adaptation finance tripled by 2035 from a $40bn annual baseline.
It is Türkiye’s voluntary initiative to raise electricity to 35 per cent of final energy demand by 2035, from roughly a fifth today, backed by about 75 nations. The draft deal nods to the goal, but critics note it does not require the extra electricity to come from clean sources rather than coal or gas.
COP31 is scheduled to end on Friday 20 November, with the final text due by midnight in Antalya. But recent climate summits have regularly run more than 24 hours past their deadlines, and observers expect at least one extra night of talks. Australia’s Chris Bowen has pledged negotiators will not leave until they have consensus.
MAGNA BUREAU