Skip to main content
ENFR SearchSubscribe

No single capital owns the whole truth

The Wire

Burnham says Brexit ‘has not worked’ as Britain heads for a reset with Europe

Prime Minister Andy Burnham told the Lord Mayor’s Banquet on Monday that Britain has “lost more than we have gained” in the decade since Brexit, and set three tests for the deals he hopes to sign at Friday’s UK-EU summit in Brussels.

The Palace of Westminster in London, seen from Westminster Bridge, with the Elizabeth Tower on the right
The Palace of Westminster in London, seen from Westminster Bridge. Britain’s prime minister told the Lord Mayor’s Banquet on Monday that Brexit ‘has not worked’.CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Key points

  • On Monday 16 November 2026, Prime Minister Andy Burnham told the Lord Mayor’s Banquet in London that Brexit “has not worked” and Britain has “lost more than we have gained” in ten years. Al Jazeera; PA Media, 16–17 Nov 2026
  • A UK-EU summit takes place in Brussels on Friday 20 November 2026, where Burnham will meet Ursula von der Leyen and António Costa; a joint declaration is expected. Al Jazeera; Sky News, 16–17 Nov 2026
  • Any deal must pass three tests: consistency with Labour’s manifesto and red lines, an improvement on the Brexit deal, and the Makerfield test of real improvements for neglected communities. PA Media; Sky News, 16 Nov 2026
  • The package on the table covers food and farming trade, energy and emissions trading, and a youth mobility scheme; the government puts the gain at 0.4 percent of GDP, about £17 billion. The Guardian, via Times of India; PA Media, 16 Nov 2026
  • Britain voted 52 percent to 48 percent to leave the EU on 23 June 2016 and formally left on 31 January 2020; Burnham, who became prime minister in September 2026, is the seventh prime minister since the referendum. Al Jazeera; Times of India, 16–17 Nov 2026

ONE EVENT. THREE READINGS.

West

The speech reads as a taboo broken.

A sitting British prime minister has called the Brexit settlement a failure in the City of London, four days before negotiating with Brussels; something no predecessor attempted.

What this reading highlights: The Western debate is now about whether the package is substance or symbolism, and whether Barnier’s warning, that the single market cannot be rejoined piece by piece, leaves Burnham anywhere to go beyond it.

Sources: PA Media, via Glasgow Times (1), Sky News, via Manx Radio (1)

East

The story is about a Europe re-knitting itself while Asia watches the terms.

China Daily carried the speech straight, noting Burnham’s criticism of a relationship with China that had “blown hot and cold”.

What this reading highlights: Beijing reads a Britain seeking shelter in its old neighbourhood; Delhi notes the charge that London failed to invest in the modernisation of the Commonwealth.

Sources: China Daily (1), Times of India (1)

Global South

The speech is heard as an admission.

Al Jazeera led with the verdict that Brexit had failed, and Türkiye’s Anadolu news agency stressed that Britain left the EU “on bad terms with bad feeling”.

What this reading highlights: For the South, the question is whether a Britain that re-engages Europe will also re-engage the wider world it promised to prioritise; or whether the Commonwealth line in Burnham’s speech was rhetoric rather than a plan.

Sources: Al Jazeera (1), Anadolu, via Free Malaysia Today (1)

Sources by lens: 2 West, 2 East, 2 Global South. See every source

THE POINT OF CONVERGENCE

On Monday 16 November 2026, Prime Minister Andy Burnham told the Lord Mayor’s Banquet in London that Brexit “has not worked” and that Britain has “lost more than we have gained” in the last ten years; a UK-EU summit takes place in Brussels on Friday 20 November 2026; and the 2016 referendum was 52 percent in favour of leaving and 48 percent in favour of remaining, with the UK formally leaving the EU on 31 January 2020.

WHAT REMAINS CONTESTED

On whether the reset is a correction or a betrayal. Burnham and his supporters say the hard Brexit delivered was not what voters were promised in 2016; critics, including two newly founded campaign groups, say any move toward closer alignment reopens a decision the country has already taken. There is also disagreement over the value of the package, with estimates of its gain ranging from £10 billion to £17 billion.

The story

A prime minister says the unsayable in the City

Britain’s prime minister has said out loud what no holder of his office has said since the referendum: Brexit has not worked. Andy Burnham told the Lord Mayor’s Banquet in London on Monday evening that the United Kingdom has “lost more than we have gained” in the ten years since the vote to leave the European Union, and that the hard Brexit the country was given “is not good enough for Britain”.

Burnham compared the Brexit settlement to Hans Christian Andersen’s tale of “The Emperor’s New Clothes”, in which no one dares tell the ruler he is naked. “I do try to say things as I see them,” he told the Guildhall audience. “And to be frank, we have lost more than we have gained in the last 10 years.”

The speech, delivered at the annual banquet in the City of London’s financial district, came four days before a UK-EU summit in Brussels on Friday 20 November, where Burnham hopes to sign a first package of new agreements with the bloc. It was the bluntest verdict on Brexit ever delivered by a sitting British prime minister,

Advertisement

What did Burnham actually promise on Monday?

Burnham set three tests for any agreement reached on Friday. First, it must be consistent with Labour’s manifesto and its red lines. Second, it must improve the Brexit deal and bring it closer to what people thought they were voting for in 2016. Third, it must pass what he called the Makerfield test: producing real improvements in people’s everyday lives in parts of the country that have felt neglected for too long. Makerfield, his own constituency around Wigan, voted by a clear majority to leave the EU in 2016.

The package on the table in Brussels covers food and farming trade, an energy and emissions-trading linkage, and a youth mobility scheme letting young people work for limited periods across Britain and the EU. The government says the package could eventually raise GDP by 0.4 percent, about £17 billion, and Burnham argued it would cut the cost of the weekly shop, reduce paperwork for exporters and lower electricity bills.

What the package does not do is cross Labour’s red lines. Burnham remains bound by the pledge of his predecessor, Keir Starmer, not to rejoin the bloc’s tariff-free customs union or its frictionless single market, and freedom of movement is also excluded. His spokesman, Tom Wells, said on Monday that “no assumptions are being made” about the longer term, and that “the British public will be the boss of any outcome”. The machinery of the bloc’s institutions will test that promise quickly enough: any deeper alignment needs Brussels to agree, and agreement has a price.

Burnham also used the banquet to settle the timing of his wider programme. His ten-year “Plan for Britain”, which he described as a circuit breaker and a roadmap to a resurgent Britain, will be published in December, after reports that it might slip into the new year.

Andy Burnham told the Lord Mayor’s Banquet in London on Monday evening that the United Kingdom has “lost more than we have gained” in the ten years since the vote to leave the European Union.

What the numbers still cannot settle

Friday’s summit may produce signed agreements, or it may produce a joint declaration and more negotiation. The food and farming deal, the energy linkage and the youth mobility scheme are all described as ready or near-ready, but none has been published, and the terms of youth mobility in particular, how long young people could stay, and in what numbers, remain undisclosed.

The economics are contested in both directions. Burnham told the banquet that estimates of the damage Brexit has done range from 4 percent to 8 percent of GDP, The claimed upside is contested too: earlier estimates put the summit package’s gain at £10 billion, against the £17 billion figure attached to it this week. Neither figure is money in hand.

Nor is it clear what Burnham’s promised national conversation about Britain’s long-term relationship with the EU will actually decide. He said he would open the discussion with EU partners soon after the summit, but he has not said what options it would cover, or whether the public would be asked to endorse any of them.

Why a speech in the City matters beyond Britain

Burnham framed Brexit as the opening act of a wider retreat. “Brexit was the first domino to fall in a global move towards more isolationism and protectionism,” he said. “It is exactly what our enemies wanted. Russia wanted disunity within NATO and a weaker Europe.”

He was unsparing about the decade that followed the referendum. “In the decade since Brexit, our standing in the world has diminished,” he said. “We treated both allies and institutions with insufficient care, and the effects went beyond Europe.” Britain, he said, had failed to invest in the modernisation of the Commonwealth and had “blown hot and cold” in relations with China, while criticising the approach taken to Israel before he became prime minister.

The speech matters because it breaks a taboo that has held British politics for a decade. Since 2016, prime ministers have defended, managed or quietly regretted Brexit; none has called the settlement a failure in the City days before negotiating with Brussels. Europe’s changing view of America has made the moment sharper still: a continent rethinking its alliances is watching to see whether London means what its prime minister says.

Why Burnham chose this week to say it

The banquet speech was not Burnham’s first attempt at the argument. He had already said on Saturday, at the Welsh Labour conference in Llandudno, that Britain has “lost more than we have gained” over the past ten years, blaming the Conservatives for delivering a harder Brexit than people expected and for burning bridges with the EU afterwards. The Guildhall speech took the same words and gave them the full weight of a prime ministerial foreign-policy address.

The timing is deliberate. Friday’s summit is the first major set-piece of Burnham’s foreign policy since he became prime minister in September, replacing Keir Starmer, and it is the second EU-UK summit after the first in London in 2025. He will meet European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and European Council President António Costa, and the leaders are expected to issue a joint declaration.

Domestically, the politics cut both ways. Two new campaign groups have been founded in recent days to keep Britain out of the EU should Burnham seek to rejoin, and his opponents will call the speech the first step back. But the welcome was immediate from those who want closer ties: Naomi Smith, chief executive of Best for Britain, which campaigns for the UK to restore EU membership, welcomed the remarks. Burnham has been moving this way for weeks: in October he told the Sunday Times he was open to discussing a return to free movement, and to considering options including possibly rejoining the bloc one day.

The counterweight comes from Brussels itself. Michel Barnier, the EU’s former chief Brexit negotiator, told the BBC on Sunday that the UK cannot rejoin the single market piece by piece, and that there is no possibility of having one of the bloc’s freedoms without the others. That warning frames the negotiation Burnham is entering: associate membership models and sectoral deals are the only ground between the red lines and the door he has just opened.

What a reset sets in motion

If Friday delivers, the consequences will arrive slowly and then all at once. The food and farming agreement would remove post-Brexit checks on food and agricultural exports, the kind of friction that has cost British exporters since 2021. Industry groups expect entry into force no sooner than a year after the summit, so the promised savings will not be felt this winter.

The energy linkage would tie Britain’s emissions trading to the EU’s, and the youth mobility scheme would reopen a door that closed in 2020 for a generation that has never known free movement. The package is also expected to touch Gibraltar, whose arrangements with the bloc have been negotiated on a separate track. Financial services, the City’s core interest, are not on the table this week, and industry body TheCityUK has urged the government to pursue closer relations on security while resisting some EU regulation on data and risk.

Brussels, for its part, will want something in return. Senior figures in the EU want the UK to begin paying for access to the European programmes it says it wants to join. The same week, the EU moved to revive its shelved association agreement with Syria, a reminder that Brussels is in a season of re-engagement; and that every such opening is negotiated, priced and conditioned.

Brussels, Friday

Burnham travels to Brussels on Friday 20 November for the summit with von der Leyen and Costa. The test is whether the food, energy and youth mobility package is signed, and whether the joint declaration opens the longer conversation he promised. After that comes the “Plan for Britain” in December, and a domestic argument about Europe that, after a decade of avoidance, is now being held in the open.

What we agree on, and what remains open

Established

  • On Monday 16 November 2026, Prime Minister Andy Burnham told the Lord Mayor’s Banquet in London that Brexit “has not worked” and that Britain has “lost more than we have gained” in the last ten years.
  • A UK-EU summit takes place in Brussels on Friday 20 November 2026.
  • The 2016 referendum was 52 percent in favour of leaving and 48 percent in favour of remaining, with the UK formally leaving the EU on 31 January 2020.

Contested

  • On whether the reset is a correction or a betrayal. Burnham and his supporters say the hard Brexit delivered was not what voters were promised in 2016.
  • Critics, including two newly founded campaign groups, say any move toward closer alignment reopens a decision the country has already taken. There is also disagreement over the value of the package, with estimates of its gain ranging from £10 billion to £17 billion.

Still open

  • Whether Friday’s summit will produce signed agreements or only a joint declaration.
  • The final terms of the youth mobility scheme.
  • What Burnham’s promised national conversation about the long-term relationship will cover or conclude.
  • Or whether the claimed 0.4 percent GDP gain will survive contact with the final text.

What to watch

Burnham to publish his ten-year Plan for Britain.

Questions, answered

Speaking at the Lord Mayor’s Banquet in London on Monday 16 November 2026, Burnham said Brexit “has not worked” and that Britain has “lost more than we have gained” in the last ten years. He compared the Brexit settlement to “The Emperor’s New Clothes” and said the hard Brexit Britain was given “is not good enough for Britain”.

Sources by lens

West (2)
East (2)
4China Daily(17 Nov 2026)
5Times of India(16 Nov 2026)
Global South (2)
1Al Jazeera(17 Nov 2026)

Open access ends December 31 — from January 1, 2027, the depth is for members.

See membership