Skip to main content
ENFR SearchSubscribe

No single capital owns the whole truth

The Wire

Italy approves antisemitism law enshrining the IHRA definition despite free-speech warnings

Italy’s Chamber of Deputies approved the bill by 147 votes to 93 late on Tuesday, rejecting every opposition amendment. The law creates no new crime or penalty, but it writes the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance definition of antisemitism into Italian law; and its critics warn the definition will chill debate about Israel and the Palestinians.

The International Criminal Court building in The Hague, Netherlands, seat of the court sanctioned by the United States
The International Criminal Court building in The Hague. Italy’s new law turns a 2016 working definition of antisemitism into domestic law, anchoring its national strategy to that text.Wikimedia Commons contributor, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Key points

  • Italy’s Chamber of Deputies gave final approval to the antisemitism bill late on Tuesday 17 November, by 147 votes to 93, with five lawmakers abstaining, after rejecting every opposition amendment. <span class=”src”><a href=”https://www.reuters.com/world/italy-approves-antisemitism-law-amid-leftist-opposition-protests-2026-11-18/” target=”_blank” rel=”noopener”>Reuters</a> (18 Nov 2026)</span>
  • The law writes the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) working definition of antisemitism, adopted in May 2016, into Italian law, including its contemporary examples. <span class=”src”><a href=”https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2026/11/italy-a-bleak-day-for-freedom-of-expression-as-parliament-votes-through-repressive-definition-of-antisemitism-into-law/” target=”_blank” rel=”noopener”>Amnesty International</a> (17 Nov 2026)</span>
  • It creates no new crimes, financial penalties or criminal sanctions; it sets principles for implementing Italy’s existing strategy against antisemitism, with a three-year strategy, a national coordinator and a database to monitor incidents. <span class=”src”><a href=”https://www.reuters.com/world/italy-approves-antisemitism-law-amid-leftist-opposition-protests-2026-11-18/” target=”_blank” rel=”noopener”>Reuters</a> (18 Nov 2026)</span>
  • The Senate had approved the bill in March 2026 by 105 votes to 24, with 21 abstentions; the government had already adopted the IHRA definition by cabinet resolution in January 2020. <span class=”src”><a href=”https://www.palestinechronicle.com/italys-antisemitism-bill-and-the-equation-that-seeks-to-make-zionism-untouchable/” target=”_blank” rel=”noopener”>Palestine Chronicle</a> (12 Sep 2026)</span>
  • The CDEC Foundation’s Antisemitism Observatory recorded 963 antisemitic incidents in Italy in 2025, about 10 percent more than the 877 recorded in 2024 and more than double the number reported in 2023. <span class=”src”><a href=”https://www.reuters.com/world/italy-approves-antisemitism-law-amid-leftist-opposition-protests-2026-11-18/” target=”_blank” rel=”noopener”>Reuters</a> (18 Nov 2026)</span>

ONE EVENT. THREE READINGS.

West

From Rome and Washington, the law reads as a democracy equipping itself: a parliament giving its police, schools and courts a shared definition after the steepest rise in antisemitic incidents in years, with a guarantee that political criticism survives untouched.

The definition is not new, the United States State Department, universities and major institutions already use it, and the government adopted it as policy in 2020.

What this reading highlights: In this reading the vote is continuity, not rupture, and the opposition’s warnings are politics as much as principle.

Sources: France 24 (1), Reuters (1), Amnesty International (1), The Times of Israel (1)

East

From Istanbul and across the region, the vote reads differently.

TRT World gave prominent space to Francesca Albanese, the UN special rapporteur on Palestine, who asked why Israeli culture should be taught in Italy at all; a question that captures how the bill is seen where criticism of Israel is mainstream politics.

What this reading highlights: For audiences in Türkiye and the wider Middle East, a European parliament legislating the boundary of speech about Israel, in the Gaza war’s aftermath, looks like the continent choosing a definition its own drafter warned against codifying, while its streets were full of protesters saying the opposite.

Sources: TRT World (1)

Global South

The story is about who writes the rules of speech.

The Palestine Chronicle, which followed the bill from the Senate vote through the September protests, frames it as one front in a wider campaign to make criticism of Israel legally risky, noting that the bill’s own examples turn seven of the definition’s eleven illustrations toward the Israeli state.

What this reading highlights: Amnesty International’s warning, that the law heightens the risk of censorship and self-censorship, travels furthest here, where more than a hundred organisations had urged the United Nations, in 2023, not to adopt the definition.

The vote in Rome is read as a signal to other capitals weighing the same step.

Sources: Associated Press, via La Nación (1), Palestine Chronicle (1)

Sources by lens: 4 West, 1 East, 2 Global South. See every source

THE POINT OF CONVERGENCE

On the core sequence; the Senate approved the bill in March 2026; the Chamber of Deputies gave final approval late on Tuesday 17 November by 147 votes to 93, with five abstentions; the law adopts the IHRA working definition of antisemitism, including its examples, into Italian law; it creates no new crimes or penalties; it provides for a three-year national strategy, a national coordinator and a database to monitor incidents; and the CDEC Observatory recorded 963 antisemitic incidents in 2025, about 10 percent more than in 2024.

WHAT REMAINS CONTESTED

On whether the law chills free speech. The government and the Jewish community leadership say the definition is a necessary yardstick, expressly protects political criticism, and changes nothing about what Italians may say. Amnesty International, opposition parties and the UN rapporteurs say giving the definition legal force risks censorship and self-censorship, because its examples cover some forms of criticism of Israel. We also disagree on whether Italy is the first country to write the definition directly into binding law.

The story

147 votes, one definition, a decade of argument settled in law

Italy’s Chamber of Deputies gave final approval late on Tuesday 17 November to a law that writes the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) working definition of antisemitism into Italian law, ending a parliamentary journey that began in the Senate in March. The lower house approved the bill by 147 votes to 93, with five lawmakers abstaining, after rejecting every opposition amendment, including one that would have replaced the IHRA text with the 2021 Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism.

The law, formally, “Measures for countering antisemitism and for the adoption of the working definition of antisemitism”, creates no new crime. Instead it anchors Italy’s existing national strategy against antisemitism to the IHRA definition, adopted by the alliance in May 2016, and by the Italian government in January 2020, examples included, and sets a three-year strategy, a national coordinator and a database to monitor incidents.

Meloni’s coalition carried the vote with Italia Viva. The Democratic Party, the main opposition force, voted against, though a small group of its reformist deputies abstained in defiance of the leadership ; the Senate had approved the bill in March by 105 votes to 24.

Advertisement

What does the law actually change?

The first article adopts the IHRA working definition, which describes antisemitism as “a certain perception of Jews, which may be expressed as hatred toward Jews”. Its accompanying examples, the most contested part of the text, include denying Jews the right to self-determination, comparing contemporary Israeli policies with those of Nazi Germany, and holding Jews collectively responsible for Israel’s actions. The definition itself states that criticism of Israel similar to criticism levelled at any other country cannot, by itself, be regarded as antisemitic.

The same article expressly preserves freedom of political criticism and expression; the safeguard the government cites against every warning of a chill. The law frames a national strategy renewed every three years, on a proposal from a national coordinator appointed by the prime minister, covering incident monitoring, training for teachers and law enforcement, prevention in universities, and action against online hate.

The debate has sharpened since the Hamas-led attacks of 7 October 2023 and the war in Gaza that followed, which fuelled a surge in antisemitic incidents across Europe and a heated argument about where criticism of Israel ends; a tension visible in the West Bank, where settler attacks have surged. On 9 September, protesters gathered at Montecitorio and in more than forty piazzas across Italy under the slogan that criticising Israel is not antisemitism and anti-Zionism is not antisemitism. It had passed the Senate in March and the Chamber’s constitutional affairs committee on 30 September, entering general debate on 2 October.

The government’s figures come from the Antisemitism Observatory of the CDEC Foundation in Milan. It recorded 963 antisemitic incidents in Italy in 2025, about 10 percent more than the 877 recorded in 2024 and more than double the number reported in 2023. Its director, Gadi Luzzatto Voghera, told Reuters the centre also recorded 18 physical assaults in 2025, and 10 more in the first half of this year.

The law, formally, “Measures for countering antisemitism and for the adoption of the working definition of antisemitism”, creates no new crime.

What Rome has not yet decided

Nothing published names the national coordinator, sets the strategy’s budget, or fixes the date of the three-year plan. How the police database will classify an incident, and who decides whether a slogan meets the definition, is not spelled out, and no court has yet tested the definition as a legal standard.

How universities will apply the text is also unclear. An earlier provision letting university officials formally flag events as breaching the definition was removed from the Senate text after criticism from across the spectrum, including within Meloni’s own Brothers of Italy. Whether administrators will still invoke the law, and whether the government will use it for decisions on demonstrations, a power the original draft contained and the final version dropped, remains to be seen.

Amnesty International called the vote “a bleak day for freedom of expression”; the government insists no criticism is touched. Between those readings sits the question the law does not answer: where, in a classroom or a newsroom or a police report, does the definition begin to bite?

Why a definition became the whole argument

Definitions rarely become law, which is why this vote matters beyond Rome. The IHRA text was written in 2016 as a non-binding working definition, a tool for monitors. Its own principal drafter, Kenneth Stern, has warned that it should never be turned into law. Italy has now done exactly that, and, according to reporting on the bill, it is the first country to write the definition into binding national legislation rather than adopting it by resolution, as others have done.

The stakes are visible in the numbers. Antisemitic incidents in Italy have climbed steeply since the Hamas-led attacks of 7 October 2023 and the war in Gaza that followed, and Jewish community leaders say a common legal yardstick is overdue. At the same time, pro-Palestinian activism has surged across Europe, and the movements filling Italian streets argue the same yardstick will be pointed at them. Europe is in a season of rewriting its rulebooks: Brussels has revived its shelved cooperation deal with Syria, and Morocco has warned Brussels not to sideline its car industry under new “Made in Europe” rules.

The argument is not about whether antisemitism should be fought, no party in the Chamber said otherwise, but about who draws the line between hatred of Jews and criticism of a state. A definition that names criticism of Israel as a possible example of antisemitism, while also insisting that comparable criticism is not antisemitic, leaves that line to be drawn case by case, by officials, teachers and judges who now have a statute to point to.

Why Meloni’s coalition wanted this vote now

The timing is not accidental. The bill reached the Chamber after Senate approval, after the September protests showed the depth of opposition, and after months of absorbed criticism; then passed unchanged. That sequence tells its own story: Meloni’s coalition was willing to pay the political price of a divisive vote because only a statute fixes the definition before the next argument begins.

The coalition’s calculation is visible in the vote itself. The centre-right held together, Italia Viva joined it, and the opposition split: the Democratic Party voted no but could not hold its reformist wing, which abstained rather than follow the leadership. For a government that has accused parts of the pro-Palestinian movement of fomenting disorder, the law is both instrument and marker; a way to say, in law, where the state stands.

There is a European dimension too: as governments across the continent weigh how to police speech about Israel and Gaza, Rome has moved first and furthest. Whether Italy becomes a model or a cautionary tale will be decided by the first cases the definition is used to judge.

What happens when a definition meets a courtroom

The law’s second-order effects will arrive quietly, in administrative decisions. The first will be the database: once incidents are classified under the IHRA definition, the count becomes a political fact, cited as proof the law was needed; or, if it sweeps in political speech, as proof it overreached.

The second will be in schools and universities, where training and prevention duties give administrators a text to apply to events, speakers and student groups. Removing the university-flagging provision shows the government knows the ground is sensitive; it does not remove the sensitivity.

The third will be abroad: if Italy’s experiment is seen to work, other governments will copy it. If the first prosecution or protest ban under the definition becomes a European cause célèbre, Rome’s law becomes the example critics cite. Either way, the definition has left the realm of guidance and entered the realm of precedent.

Will the first test come from a campus or a court?

Next is the administration: the prime minister names a coordinator, who drafts the first three-year strategy. The names, budget and timetable will show how seriously the government intends to enforce the text.

Then the first application. A complaint about a university event, a police report citing the definition, or a legal challenge under Italy’s constitutional free-speech guarantees would each test the statute in a different forum. Amnesty’s warning and the UN rapporteurs’ criticism suggest a challenge is likely, in an Italian court or in Strasbourg.

And the count: the CDEC Observatory’s next annual figure will be read as the law’s first report card; vigilance to supporters, overreach to critics. The number will be argued over before it is published.

What we agree on, and what remains open

Established

  • On the core sequence; the Senate approved the bill in March 2026.
  • The Chamber of Deputies gave final approval late on Tuesday 17 November by 147 votes to 93, with five abstentions.
  • The law adopts the IHRA working definition of antisemitism, including its examples, into Italian law.
  • It creates no new crimes or penalties.
  • It provides for a three-year national strategy, a national coordinator and a database to monitor incidents.
  • The CDEC Observatory recorded 963 antisemitic incidents in 2025, about 10 percent more than in 2024.

Contested

  • On whether the law chills free speech. The government and the Jewish community leadership say the definition is a necessary yardstick, expressly protects political criticism, and changes nothing about what Italians may say. Amnesty International, opposition parties and the UN rapporteurs say giving the definition legal force risks censorship and self-censorship, because its examples cover some forms of criticism of Israel. We also disagree on whether Italy is the first country to write the definition directly into binding law.

Still open

  • Who will be named national coordinator, or when.
  • What budget the three-year strategy will carry.
  • How the incident database will classify cases, and who decides.
  • How universities and police will apply the definition in practice.
  • Whether the law will face a constitutional challenge in Italy or in Strasbourg.
  • Or what the CDEC Observatory’s next annual count will show.

Questions, answered

The Chamber of Deputies gave final approval on 17 November to a law adopting the IHRA working definition of antisemitism, by 147 votes to 93 with five abstentions. The Senate had approved the bill in March. The law anchors Italy’s national strategy against antisemitism to the 2016 definition, including its examples, and provides for a three-year strategy, a national coordinator and a database to monitor incidents.

Sources by lens

West (4)
1France 24(18 Nov 2026)
2Reuters(18 Nov 2026)
4Amnesty International(17 Nov 2026)
7The Times of Israel(18 Nov 2026)
East (1)
5TRT World(3 Oct 2026)
Global South (2)
6Palestine Chronicle(12 Sep 2026)

Open access ends December 31 — from January 1, 2027, the depth is for members.

See membership