Skip to main content
MAGNA BUREAU
BUREAU

No single capital owns the whole truth

The Wire

Thousands march across Israel demanding a Jewish-Arab coalition to oust Netanyahu

From Habima Square to Paris Square, protesters urged opposition leader Gadi Eisenkot to turn the opposition's 48 seats and the Arab parties' record 19 into a 67-seat government; as Netanyahu called the idea ‘a disaster for Israel’.

The summary

On Saturday evening, October 31, coordinated marches called by Standing Together demanded a Jewish-Arab coalition government: about 500 people at Habima Square in Tel Aviv (AFP), about 100 at Paris Square in Jerusalem, plus rallies in Haifa, Beersheba and the Tira-Taibeh Triangle; Haaretz put nationwide turnout in the thousands. The October 27 election left a 120-seat Knesset split 67 to 53: 48 seats for anti-Netanyahu Jewish-majority parties and a record combined 19 for Ra’am and the Joint List; the arithmetic behind the ‘67 mandates for change’ placards.

The three lenses

Read the full story
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu: on October 31, protesters in Tel Aviv, Jerusalem, Haifa, Beersheba and Tayibe demanded the opposition build a Jewish-Arab coalition to end his rule. Office of Speaker Mike Johnson, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Advertisement

Key facts

  • On Saturday evening, October 31, coordinated marches called by Standing Together demanded a Jewish-Arab coalition government: about 500 people at Habima Square in Tel Aviv (AFP), about 100 at Paris Square in Jerusalem, plus rallies in Haifa, Beersheba and the Tira-Taibeh Triangle; Haaretz put nationwide turnout in the thousands. AFP, via Malay Mail (Nov 1, 2026); the five-city marches and crowd counts
  • The October 27 election left a 120-seat Knesset split 67 to 53: 48 seats for anti-Netanyahu Jewish-majority parties and a record combined 19 for Ra’am and the Joint List; the arithmetic behind the ‘67 mandates for change’ placards. The Hindu (AFP wire) (Nov 1, 2026); the 48+19=67 math
  • Opposition leader Gadi Eisenkot, 66, former military chief and Yashar party head, said October 31 he would only form a ‘Zionist government’ committed to Israel as a Jewish, democratic and liberal state and to Hamas as a terrorist organization; that evening he announced four coalition principles open to any MK who accepts them. Vietnam+ (VNA) (Nov 1, 2026); Eisenkot’s conditions and four principles
  • Benjamin Netanyahu called cooperation with Arab parties ‘a disaster for Israel’ in a Saturday social-media post and has accused Arab politicians of Qatari backing and electoral irregularities; claims rejected by Doha and twice dismissed by Israel’s election referee. The Thursday Times (Nov 1, 2026); Netanyahu’s offensive and the Qatar claims
  • Ra’am leader Mansour Abbas, whose party is the only Arab party ever to sit in an Israeli government (2021–2022), is willing to do so again; Joint List leader Yousef Jabareen offers outside parliamentary support, citing Gaza; Yair Golan backs inclusion and met Abbas October 29, while Avigdor Liberman rules out any Arab-reliant coalition. Haaretz (Oct 31, 2026); the parties’ positions
  • President Isaac Herzog is expected by Thursday, November 5, to hand a party leader the mandate to form a government: 28 days of negotiations with a possible 14-day extension. Aaj English TV (AFP wire) (Nov 1, 2026); the mandate timeline

What did the marchers demand on Habima Square?

On Saturday evening, October 31, 2026, hundreds of Israelis filled Habima Square in Tel Aviv demanding a government built on a Jewish-Arab partnership. Around 500 people, according to Agence France-Presse, gathered at the square from about 7:30 p.m., carrying placards that read “Arabs and Jews will only win together,” “There is a majority for change” and “67 mandates for change,” before marching toward Rabin Square.

The Tel Aviv rally was the largest of a coordinated evening of marches called by Standing Together, the grassroots movement that campaigns for Jewish-Arab political partnership. Parallel demonstrations took place at Paris Square in Jerusalem (about 100 people, per AFP, with signs reading “67; United we stand, divided we get Bibi”); outside the Haifa auditorium; at the Performing Arts Center in Beersheba; and in the Triangle area between the Arab cities of Tira and Taibeh. Haaretz, which covered the rallies with its own reporters and photographers, put the nationwide turnout in the thousands.

The demand: opposition leader Gadi Eisenkot should convert Tuesday’s inconclusive result, 48 seats for anti-Netanyahu Jewish-majority parties plus a record 19 for the two Arab-led lists, into a 67-seat majority that removes Benjamin Netanyahu from power. Chants included “Jews and Arabs refuse to be enemies,” “No to racism, yes to partnership” and “The people have decided; Jewish-Arab partnership.”

The evening was not unopposed. More than 100 Netanyahu supporters staged a counter-protest on the sidelines of the Tel Aviv rally, according to AFP, Haaretz put their number at a few dozen, chanting “Bibi, King of Israel” and “The people demand new elections.” Police detained one activist on suspicion of disturbing public order. It was the second such mobilization in three days: on Thursday, about 200 people had gathered outside Eisenkot’s home in Herzliya with the same demand.

Where does the number 67 come from?

Tuesday’s general election, on October 27, left neither bloc with a majority in Israel’s 120-seat Knesset, where 61 seats are needed to govern. The final count, reported by Vietnam’s VNA news agency, gave the opposition 67 seats against 53 for the bloc backing Netanyahu. Inside the opposition’s total: 48 seats for Jewish-majority parties opposed to Netanyahu, and a combined 19 for the two Arab-majority lists, Ra’am (the United Arab List) and the Joint List, a record result that redrew Israel’s coalition map.

Advertisement

At the center: Gadi Eisenkot, 66, the former military chief who leads the Yashar party and is the opposition’s leading candidate to form the next government. Mansour Abbas leads Ra’am, the only Arab party ever to sit formally in an Israeli government (2021–2022), and says he would do so again. Yousef Jabareen leads the Joint List and told AFP he would back Eisenkot in parliament without joining his government, citing the Gaza war. Veteran Arab MP Ahmad Tibi says his camp is ready to back the opposition.

Eisenkot’s answer, so far, is a formula. On Saturday he reiterated he would only form a “Zionist government” whose members recognize Israel as a “Jewish, democratic and liberal state” and Hamas as a terrorist organization; conditions Arab leaders have previously refused. That evening he announced four principles he said would anchor any new coalition, open to any MK who accepts them.

The opposition is split: Yair Golan, leader of the left-wing Democrats, backs a government supported by Arab parties, calling exclusion racist, and met Abbas on October 29. Avigdor Liberman, head of the right-wing anti-Netanyahu Yisrael Beiteinu, has ruled out any coalition relying on Arab parties, even outside support.

Will Eisenkot actually pick up the phone?

Everything hinges on a decision Eisenkot has not made: whether to seek the mandate to form a government and, if he gets it, whether to negotiate seriously with Abbas and Jabareen. He has said he does not want a government dependent on Arab lists, but he has not explicitly rejected their external support; a deliberate ambiguity the marches were designed to break.

Nor is the 67 arithmetic guaranteed to survive the Knesset: Liberman’s veto strains the idea that all 48 anti-Netanyahu seats move as one bloc, and Eisenkot’s conditions strain it from the other side. Unknown: whether any Arab leader accepts the “Zionist government” formula, whether Jabareen’s outside-support offer, Gaza war cited, is the ceiling of what is possible, and what Netanyahu tries next.

Why has the arithmetic never looked like this before?

Because 19 seats is not a protest vote; it is kingmaker territory. Arab citizens make up around 20 percent of Israel’s population, and on Tuesday they converted anger at rhetoric targeting their community from Netanyahu’s hard-right government into the largest Arab representation in the Knesset’s history. For the first time, the road to 61 runs through the Arab lists, and everyone in Israeli politics knows it.

Netanyahu has answered by going on the offensive against the minority’s leaders; calling cooperation with Arab parties “a disaster for Israel” and accusing Arab politicians of Qatari backing and electoral irregularities, claims Doha rejected and Israel’s election referee twice dismissed. The street’s answer, from Habima to Paris Square: two decades of treating Arab votes as illegitimate are over.

The precedent exists, barely: Ra’am’s 2021–2022 stint remains the only time an Arab party has formally sat in an Israeli government. What the protesters are demanding is not a repeat of that fragile experiment but its normalization; Arab parties as permanent, legitimate partners in power rather than a one-off exception.

The 67-seat majority exists on paper. Does it exist in the Knesset?

67 is a maximum, not a bloc: it assumes all 48 anti-Netanyahu Jewish-majority seats and all 19 Arab seats move together; and Liberman has already said his party will not. Subtract Yisrael Beiteinu and the celebrated 67 dissolves before negotiations start, which is why Netanyahu’s allies sound relaxed and the protesters sounded urgent.

Eisenkot’s formula is the second strain. A “Zionist government” whose members must recognize Israel as a Jewish state and Hamas as a terrorist organization is, as drafted, a door built to stay closed: Arab leaders have refused those conditions before, and nothing in the last 72 hours suggests they have moved. His Saturday-evening four principles, open, he said, to any MK who accepts them, may be the bridge, or may be the same wall with better lighting. The exit polls that first showed the Arab surge did not show anyone’s red lines moving.

Netanyahu’s counter-strategy is clearer: make the Arab parties politically toxic before talks begin. The Qatar allegations, the “ disaster for Israel” post, the offensive against the minority’s leaders; each raises the price Eisenkot would pay for picking up the phone. The marches were an attempt to change that price from the other side: to make exclusion, not inclusion, the politically expensive choice.

What changes if Arab parties become permanent kingmakers?

If the 67 math ever becomes a government, even on outside Arab support, it rewrites Israeli coalition politics. The unwritten rule since 1948: Arab parties can vote but not govern. Ra’am’s 2021–2022 stint cracked it; a second, larger iteration would normalize the anomaly, and every future election would be fought with the Arab lists as declared kingmakers.

The second-order effects run outward. Arab capitals that signed normalization deals are watching whether Israel’s Arab citizens gain real governing power or remain a demographic fact with no ministerial address. Inside Israel, Standing Together’s mobilization, two coordinated national evenings in three days, suggests the Jewish-Arab partnership street has an organizational spine now, not just a slogan. And Gaza hangs over all of it: any partnership that cannot survive the war’s politics, as Jabareen’s caveat warned, will not survive the Knesset either.

What happens before Herzog’s Thursday deadline?

President Isaac Herzog is expected by Thursday, November 5, to hand a party leader the mandate to form a government; 28 days of negotiations, with a possible 14-day extension. Between now and then, the watch list is short: whether Eisenkot seeks the mandate and opens formal talks with Abbas and Jabareen; whether Liberman’s veto is final or negotiable; what Netanyahu’s next offensive against the Arab lists looks like; and whether Standing Together calls the street out again.

The marches bought the idea of a Jewish-Arab government one week of momentum. The Knesset will now decide whether that week becomes a precedent; or a memory.

The three lenses

West Lens:

Western coverage has split into two registers. Haaretz worked the street: the Thursday precursor outside Eisenkot’s Herzliya home, the march from Habima to Rabin Square, the counter-protesters’ chants, the single police detention; a country arguing with itself in public. The AFP wire, carried across Asia and the Gulf, worked the arithmetic: 48 plus 19 equals 67, set against Eisenkot’s “Zionist government” conditions and Liberman’s veto.

East Lens:

The East covered the marches as a government-formation story, numbers first. Vietnam’s VNA agency reported the 7:30 p.m. start times across the five cities, the final 67-to-53 count, and named all four opposition parties, Eisenkot’s Yashar, Bennett’s B’Yachad, Golan’s Democrats and Liberman’s Yisrael Beiteinu, alongside Abbas, Jabareen and Tibi on the Arab side. No identity drama in the Eastern telling, only coalition mechanics: who holds how many seats, who said what on October 30 and 31, what Eisenkot’s four principles require.

South Lens:

The Global South read the marches through representation; and through Gaza. Al Jazeera put the story in its newsfeed within hours, describing the demand as cooperation with “Palestinian-Israeli parties,” a framing no Western outlet used. Pakistan’s Thursday Times dwelled on the counter-protesters accusing Arab parties of backing Hamas, and on Netanyahu’s Qatar allegations.

The consensus

What we agree on
We agree: the verified core is not in dispute, on Saturday evening, October 31, coordinated marches called by Standing Together filled Habima Square in Tel Aviv (about 500, per AFP), Paris Square in Jerusalem (about 100), plus Haifa, Beersheba and the Tira-Taibeh Triangle, demanding opposition leader Gadi Eisenkot ally with Ra’am and the Joint List, a record combined 19 seats; to build a 67-seat Jewish-Arab majority and remove Benjamin Netanyahu; more than 100 Netanyahu supporters counter-protested in Tel Aviv and police detained one activist.
What we don't agree on
We disagree: on whether the 67-seat arithmetic can become a government, a legitimate partnership long overdue (the marchers, Yair Golan) or an arrangement that relies on parties no Zionist coalition should touch (Netanyahu, Liberman), and on whether Eisenkot’s ‘Zionist government’ conditions are a bridge to that partnership or a wall against it.
What we know
We know: the full factual record; the October 27 election left a 120-seat Knesset split 67 to 53, with 48 anti-Netanyahu Jewish-majority seats and 19 for the two Arab lists; Eisenkot’s Saturday conditions and his Saturday-evening four principles; Golan’s backing and his October 29 meeting with Abbas; Liberman’s rejection of any Arab-reliant coalition; Netanyahu’s ‘disaster for Israel’ post and his Qatar and irregularity claims, rejected by Doha and by Israel’s election referee; and the Thursday precursor rally of about 200 outside Eisenkot’s Herzliya home.
What we don't know yet
We do not know yet: whether Eisenkot will seek the mandate and negotiate with Abbas and Jabareen; whether any Arab leader can accept his conditions; whether the outcome would be full coalition membership or outside support; whether Liberman’s veto holds; or what Netanyahu’s next move against the Arab lists will be.
What we expect
We expect: Herzog’s mandate decision by Thursday, November 5; 28 days of coalition talks with a possible 14-day extension; renewed street pressure if talks stall or exclude the Arab parties; and the 67-seat question, paper majority or governing majority, to dominate Israeli politics for the coming month.

Questions, answered

Who organized the October 31 marches across Israel?

The grassroots movement Standing Together, which campaigns for Jewish-Arab political partnership, called the coordinated evening of marches starting around 7:30 p.m. Rallies took place at Habima Square in Tel Aviv, Paris Square in Jerusalem, outside the Haifa auditorium, at the Performing Arts Center in Beersheba, and in the Triangle area between Tira and Taibeh.

What is the 67-seat arithmetic the protesters chanted about?

In the 120-seat Knesset, 61 seats make a majority. Tuesday’s election gave anti-Netanyahu Jewish-majority parties 48 seats and the two Arab-led lists, Ra’am and the Joint List, a record combined 19. Together that is 67, a comfortable governing majority on paper, against 53 seats for the bloc backing Netanyahu.

Who is Gadi Eisenkot, and what conditions has he set?

Eisenkot, 66, is a former Israeli military chief who leads the Yashar party and is the opposition’s leading candidate to form the next government. On October 31 he said he would only form a ‘Zionist government’ whose members recognize Israel as a Jewish, democratic and liberal state and Hamas as a terrorist organization; conditions Arab leaders have previously refused.

Have Arab parties ever sat in an Israeli government before?

Only once. Ra’am, led by Mansour Abbas, joined the short-lived coalition that governed from 2021 to 2022; the sole case of an Arab party formally sitting in an Israeli government. Abbas has said he is willing to do so again, while Joint List leader Yousef Jabareen has offered to support Eisenkot from outside parliament, citing the Gaza war.

What happens next in the government-formation process?

President Isaac Herzog is expected by Thursday, November 5, to give a party leader the mandate to form a government. The designee then gets 28 days of negotiations, with a possible 14-day extension. The key unknowns are whether Eisenkot seeks the mandate, whether he talks to the Arab parties, and whether Liberman’s veto holds.

Sources

Loading the discussion…
Advertisement

The news starts free. The depth is funded by the people who read it.

See membership